I have been following the case of 28-year old NYPD officer
Gilberto Valle with some interest. After all, it isn’t every day you see
someone accused of “conspiracy to cook and eat women.” According to the prosecution,
Mr. Valle kept a detailed list of at least 100 women (complete with photos)
that he planned to “kidnap, rape, and torture” before dinning on their
cadavers. He allegedly used his access to the law enforcement NCIC database to
acquire personal information about his culinary interests.
Chef Valle |
Apparently Valle, who had been discussing these plans at
length with other members on a cannibalism fantasy website, had created a
document titled “Abducting and Cooking [Victim 1]: A Blueprint.” The document
contained a checklist of items he needed (car, chloroform, rope) and detailed
information about the victim. In his electronic exchanges with other Internet
cannibalism enthusiasts, the prosecution claims Officer Valle discussed the
amount of “meat” one could get from a grown woman (around 75lbs was the consensus)
and haggled over the price for kidnapping a victim (he wouldn’t take a cent
under $5,000).
Gilberto’s defense attorney argues that his client did not
actually harm anyone and that all the electronic evidence against him amounts
to nothing more than “harmless, idle talk” insisting “at worse, these are
sexual fantasies with people he knows." He has been suspended without
pay pending the completion of the investigation. There is currently no word on
the identity of his alleged co-conspirators and custody of his 1-year old son
has yet to be determined.
I am not sure which aspect of the story is more disturbing:
the fact that a police officer entertained fantasies of rape and cannibalism or
that he discovered enough like-minded individuals to constitute an online
quorum. How does a discussion group like this get off the ground? Was it the
result of a chance meeting between two former college roommates?
“Dave! How have you been?”
“Can’t complain. You?”
“Not bad, what have you been up to?”
“Funny you ask, I have really gotten into fantasizing about cannibalism but I can’t find any websites that specifically cater to heterosexual men who consider it a pseudo-erotic activity.”
“You’re tellin’ me! I joined this one chat-room and it was a real freak-show. Some dude went on for ten minutes about his Thanksgiving recipe for two sautéed Englishmen with giblets.”
“There should be a place to go for regular guys who just want to kick back, relax, and trade recipes for soccer-mom stew. Let’s get organized!”
There was even a quote from the chat-room where the guys
would share pictures of proposed victims and comment on how “tasty” they
looked. There has always been a lot of frightening stuff on the Internet, (my
wife once Googled “Peek-a-pooh” trying to recall the proper name for a Pekingese/poodle
mix) so perhaps I shouldn’t be so shocked, but this group could make members of
an amputee fetish club appear well-adjusted.
I suppose it is possible the conversations were nothing more
than verbal bluster meant to impress his friends, as we have all been guilty of
exaggeration around a group of our peers. After all, what guy hasn’t stretched
the truth a little when recalling how much they bench pressed in college or how
exactly they came about the scar on their chin? However, I generally try and
avoid the company of people who are only impressed by someone’s ability to plan
and execute a rape/murder/dinner trifecta.
I realize that the defense attorney has a job to do, but I am
concerned that he and I are operating under different understanding of what
constitutes a “worst case scenario.” If your client is openly planning the
kidnapping, rape, execution, and consumption of enough women to staff a Costco,
I assure you that amassing zero victims and a pair of felony charges is nowhere
near “worst case scenario.”
His best defense is probably the rudimentary nature of his
“blueprint.” If Valle needed a Microsoft Word checklist to remember to take his
car with him on a kidnapping, it is certainly plausible that he isn’t the criminal
mastermind the government envisioned. I wonder if the list was the result of a
failed test run whereby Gilberto found himself on foot outside the victim’s
home with rope and chloroform trying to understand how to load an unconscious
woman into a wheelbarrow.
I hope for all of our sakes the attorney was right and this
was nothing more than an unusual culinary interest that got out of hand. Either
way, if this guy starts hosting a show on the Food Network called Vixens &
Vittles, I will be writing a letter.